Buncombe County’s Tourist Development Authority began advertising for tourists to visit Asheville again – on the same day that the county’s top public health official said coronavirus cases were “rising at an alarming rate.”
The ad campaign, designed to promote “the safe and responsible return of visitation,” featured social media posts like one picturing a young couple picnicking on the bank of a river. “We invite you to pack your bags and masks, and safely experience our mountain oasis.”
On July 14, just five days after the ads began, the TDA pulled the plug. The reason: a viral surge – both of the pandemic kind, and of a social media variety.
The TDA had planned for the first scenario, monitoring Covid-19 trends in the target area, a 300-mile radius considered drivable to Asheville. When the campaign launched, large metropolitan areas like Charlotte and Atlanta were excluded because of a high viral caseload. But by mid-July, half of all the target counties had exceeded a threshold the TDA set and were considered coronavirus “hot spots,” according to documents obtained by AVL Watchdog through a public records request.
The second outcome had not been anticipated. “While all of our digital messaging communicated the importance of mask-wearing and social distancing, these messages also sometimes turned into sad platforms on social media for people to debate the wisdom of mask wearing,” Chris Cavanaugh, interim executive of the TDA, wrote to the board on July 15.
The debates, he said, had sometimes turned ugly.
“It had nothing to do with Asheville but was a sign of a larger unfortunate discussion taking place on a national basis,” Cavanaugh said in an interview Tuesday. “It’s sad, but that’s unfortunately the way people are on social media these days.”
Like other tourist destinations, Asheville is in a quandary. The stay-home orders are lifted, and many businesses are open, or partially open, but struggling mightily. Visitors can bring a needed boost – and they can bring more disease.
Nearby areas that were within the TDA advertising zone have seen some of the fastest-rising caseloads. Tennessee, South Carolina and Georgia are in the top 10 states with the most cases per 100,000 residents in the past week, according to a New York Times analysis.
“It is an issue that a lot of destinations are wrestling with,” Cavanaugh said. “Some have made the decision to go back into the market with TV advertising. I’ve seen ads for Pigeon Forge and Myrtle Beach.”
The TDA opted for ads on Facebook, Instagram and other social media platforms, targeting prospective visitors who had expressed statements suggesting they obey rules and would be “more likely to follow requested precautions, such as wearing a face covering,” a TDA document says.
The digital-only campaign allowed “the greatest amount of flexibility to pull advertising” quickly, Cavanaugh said. And that became necessary as new cases surged in neighboring states and Florida, a main source of summer visitors.
“There just literally became no places we could advertise,” Cavanaugh said. “There just weren’t enough counties that we considered safe that we could target.”
Julie Mayfield, an Asheville City Councilwoman and nonvoting member of the TDA board, questioned the wisdom of advertising for tourists when the board heard the proposal in June.
“I am certainly glad that we have stopped advertising and I wouldn’t be opposed to doing more to discourage visitors from coming here,” she wrote in an email to AVL Watchdog. “I know people are desperate to get out of their hometowns and that we provide a great destination, and I know that our businesses and workers want to get back to work, but I am concerned about the rise in cases.”
Buncombe County Commission Chairman Brownie Newman said he was aware of the TDA’s campaign and supported the decision to end it based on the data.
“I’m not that concerned about people staying in hotels per se,” he said. “It’s more people just coming into the region and going out into the public sphere — restaurants, other places where there’s a lot more interaction directly with members of the community, and that that could be a source of spread.”
Newman acknowledged local job losses from the pandemic number in the thousands.
“We’re very worried about those folks, so if the [coronavirus] numbers weren’t increasing, then that’d be great,” he said. “But they are going up.”
The TDA consulted with Newman and other government representatives before launching, said TDA spokeswoman Kathi Petersen. “They understood, agreed, and approved of these plans,” she said.
The discussions included public health officials. “Our emphasis was that any TDA marketing should emphasize the continued threat of the pandemic and need for visitors to adhere to state and local guidance,” said Stacey Wood, spokeswoman for Buncombe County Health & Human Services.
More like ‘PSAs’
The TDA controls the 6 percent occupancy tax revenue that comes from hotel and lodging stays. Its mission is to promote tourism to boost the local economy.
The TDA stopped advertising when the pandemic began, and in May, launched an online video, “Together in Spirit,” aimed to “inspire future travel, but without a call to action,” according to a July 2 marketing plan.
The short-lived social media campaign this month was meant to be a blend of “inspiration and safety,” according to the marketing plan. With research showing travelers seeking uncrowded places, the ads featured outdoor scenes and activities that allowed for social distancing.
Above one masked couple outside the Grove Arcade, the caption read: “Mask wearing is temporary, but our safety pledge is helping visitors get back to making memories that last forever.”
The ads emphasized safety “and could actually be described as ‘PSAs’ [Public Service Announcements] versus advertising,” Petersen told AVL Watchdog at the time of the launch. She defended the decision to advertise again, saying tourists are key to the city’s recovery and the survival of its small, independent businesses.
Government has stepped in with loans and assistance, including the $5 million Buncombe Tourism Jobs Recovery Fund that the TDA created to help local businesses. “But in the end, they will also need customers, more than just local residents, who will put cash in their registers,” Petersen said.
Cavanaugh said the TDA’s challenge is how to support local businesses that depend on high-volume summer sales to make it through the year without risking more infection.
“My big fear is what happens to these businesses once the colder months come, when the appeal of outdoor activities is a lot less, or when restaurants aren’t able to do outdoor dining?” he said. “What can we do to safely and responsibly invite customers for these businesses back into Asheville and help them during the time when hopefully they can earn enough income to ride out what may be a dark winter?”
With advertising on hiatus, the TDA is working with Buncombe County to erect signs in downtown, Biltmore Village and Black Mountain with reminders that masks are mandated.
“Wear a mask,” Cavanaugh said. “I can’t say that enough to anyone, whether they live here in Buncombe or are coming from Hawaii.”
The TDA plans to resume the ad campaign, though altered to avoid providing a platform for mask debates.
“I don’t know when we’ll be back,” Cavanaugh said. “It’ll probably be at least a month, but who knows?”
AVL Watchdog is a nonprofit news team producing stories that matter to Asheville and Buncombe County. Sally Kestin is a Pulitzer Prize-winning investigative reporter. Contact us at avlwatchdog@gmail.com.
I was opposed to the TDA approach of advertising particularly after witnessing lines outside Wicked Weed (big tourist destination) of maskless people jammed together, talking excitedly. Drinkers on the patio were sitting close together only the servers wearing masks. This was a trend I noticed throughout the city.
During a June visit to my hair stylist I listened to a visitor to our city complaining about “mask Nazis” ( her words) and wondering why the city was still closed up. Why would the TDA think that visitors would act responsibly?!
In my 25 years living here I’ve never seen so many out of state plates on the neighborhood roads of Kenilworth.
I know I’m in the minority but I think A-vile has oversold itself and allowed an unsustainable hotel growth with no corresponding plan to fund the infrastructure needed by the crowds: waste water fresh water, traffic management, parking, policing, affordable housing and health care services.
As a long time local, it feels like we are under siege from tourists and vacation homeowners. No one I know who’s lived here more than ten years goes downtown anymore.
Enter the virus and now the great tourism machine has ground to a halt and the only thing that will revive it may kill more Ashevillians.
May I also point out that our first Covid cases in March were from Madison county residents who had just visited NYC?
As a former City Council member I’d like to interject concerning a widespread misperception. The City has not “allowed” the extensive hotel development, that is a decision by private land owners. Under NC law a city cannot prevent anyone from building a hotel, as long as they meet relevant zoning and building codes. We tried to block one while I was on Council due to what seemed to me to be a fraudulent traffic study (the estimate of how a new business will affect traffic). The City lost that battle in court.
As for the TDA, I think it should be eliminated. And surely they ought not advertise while the Trump plague rages on.
Many of the hotel & restaurant jobs barely pay $10/hr. Not enough to pay for even a “room” to rent in a privately owned house or apt or as a “sub-renter”!! Before bringing more tourists in, make affordable housing a priority for the employees of these establishments to live in and raise the minimum wage in NC, currently at $7.25/hr
…the same rate as the Federal min wage rate…YET PAID $600/WK in unemployment benefits for months due to covid! Which = $15/hr @ 40 hrs / wk gross!! The $7.25/ hr min pay rate hasn’t increased in over a decade! Yet rental housing has increased year-over-year in AVL?? To pay $500/mo to rent just a room in a 2 bedroom apt or house is actually on the low-end of the spectrum! Many more rooms for rent avg closer to $700/mo, for 1 person! To rent a room in one of the cheapest motels in Avl = $500/wk or $2000/mo!! Nobody that earns $10/hr working a full time, 40 hr/wk job can afford this in AVL?? Yet this is where DSS put the majority of homeless people (free of charge) to live in during covid?? If /when they get a job at $10/hr, they have to find somewhere else to live! Ridiculous!! Do the math: $2000 x 12 months = $24,000/yr. For $24,000/yr, I would much rather take the $ and buy a small piece of land for $10,000 and either buy a used mobile home, RV, or tiny home to put on the land! And since it’s ALL PAID FOR & PAID OFF, they can afford to take that $10/hr job and use their earnings to pay for everything else: utilities, food, clothing, childcare, health ins premiums (even if offered at job, it’s hardly ever free!) And to pay ANNUAL Property TAXES! Giving them actual ownership, rather than just a “sense of it”? This in turn, increases intrinsic benefits as well…such as: pride in being a homeowner, a voice and/or taking action in their local communities to make them a great place to live. Offering sense of control over their own destiny, creating stability, and dare i say happiness! The property taxes they pay can then be distributed to DSS who can then use $ to help even more people own their own place the following year! Think smart, efficient use of $ before sinking it into an ad campaign for visitors first?? PLEASE! Make Avl an awesome place to live, so people will want to take jobs in hospitality industry, and make the visitors/customers that visit here see genuinely happy workers that serve them!